When Coffee & Kale Compete

When Coffee & Kale Compete

Become Great at Making Products People Will Buy

Alan Klement

Summary

This book dives deep into Customer Jobs theory and Jobs To Be Done. Essentially, rather than a product solving a person's problem, if you think of it from the customer's perspective, they are hiring your product to do a job for them. The goal of any job someone hires a product for is to improve their life.

Through both diving into the concepts as well as case studies, Alan effectively cements home what this framework of thinking about building products is and how important it is to know what job your customers are hiring your product for.

Contents

Foreword
  • Origin of Customer Jobs Theory
  • Beyond Product Attribute Quality as Value
  • An Early Example
  • JTBD Theory and Innovation Success
  • Alan’s Work and What’s Next
1 Challenges, Hope, and Progress
  • Challenges
  • Hope
  • The Progress You Can Make with Customer Jobs
  • How to Be Successful with Customer Jobs and This Book
  • About Me
  • Abandon Every MBA, All You Who Enter
2 What is a Job to be Done (JTBD)?
  • Improve Your Life-Situation; Become More Than You Are
  • A Job to be Done Defined
  • Products Enable Customers to Get A Job Done
  • What Isn’t A Job to be Done
  • Where Does Customer Jobs Theory Come From?
3 What Are the Principles of Customer Jobs?
  • Principles of Customer Jobs
4 Case Study: Dan and Clarity
  • What’s the JTBD?
  • Put It to Work
5 Case Study: Anthony and Form Theatricals
  • What’s The JTBD?
  • Put It to Work
6 Case Study: Morgan and YourGrocer
  • hat’s The JTBD?
  • Put It to Work
7 The Forces of Progress
  • Forces That Oppose Each Other
  • Unpacking Demand Generation
  • Push and Pull Shape The JTBD
  • Unpacking Demand Reduction
  • Put It to Work
8 When You Define Competition Wrong
  • Too “Kool” For School?
  • Why Did The chotuKool Flop?
  • The Mainframe Versus the PC
  • Don’t Be Fooled by Randomness
  • Put It to Work
9 Case Study: Omer and Transcendent Endeavors
  • What’s the JTBD?
  • Put It to Work
10 Case Study: Justin and Product People Club
  • What’s the JTBD?
  • Put It to Work
11 Case Study: Ash and Lean Stack
  • What’s the JTBD?
  • Put It to Work
12 The System of Progress
  • Why Study Systems and The System of Progress? I
  • nterdependencies Between Customers and Producers
  • The System’s Four Main Parts
  • The Forces of Progress That Power the System Of Progress
  • The System of Progress Is Continuous
  • Is the System of Progress New?
  • Put It to Work
13 Innovation and the System of Progress
  • The Customer Does Not Understand the System
  • Improving Interdependencies Within the System
  • When A System’s Interdependencies Change
  • Fragile Interdependencies and Cascade Effects
  • JTBD Empowers Us to Innovate
  • Put It to Work
14 How Might We Describe a Job to be Done?
  • Try It Yourself
  • Describing A JTBD
15 Get Started Today
  • Influencing Others:Customer Jobs Top Down
  • Influencing Others: Customer Jobs Bottom Up
  • Learning Customer Jobs from Others
  • JTBD.INFO Contacting Me
16 Appendix: Know the Two — Very — Different Interpretations of Jobs to be Done
  • Two Models: Jobs-As-Progress; Jobs-As-Activities
  • Do Goals Vs. Be Goals
  • Jobs-As-Activities
  • Jobs-As-Progress
  • Two Different, Incompatible Models
  • Challenges in Understanding a Tangled Mess
  • The Future? Use What’s Helpful. Don’t Assume Anything
  • References

Quotes

Upgrade your user, not your product. Don’t build better cameras—build better photographers.

—Kathy Sierra

Doctors treat patients successfully because they understand that the pains and discomforts that patients express are not the problems; they represent the patients’ interactions with their own bodies. Similarly, the needs, wants, and desired outcomes that customers express do not represent their problem; they represent interactions between the customer and the system of progress. Therefore, customers’ stated preferences are unreliable and why customers’ “needs” and “wants” keep changing.

“At 37signals [the former name of Basecamp], we’ve been thinking more about why people hire our product—or what people are hiring our product to do.” I remember at the time thinking, Man, I’ve never thought about it like that before.

Keep your mind open to what counts as competition. I recently talked with a woman who told me about switching from her morning coffee to a kale smoothie with a shot of wheatgrass. Who would’ve thought a cup of coffee and a kale smoothie could be competitors?

Questions you should be able to answer after reading this book

What is a Job to be Done?

A Job to be Done is the process a consumer goes through whenever she aims to transform her existing life-situation into a preferred one, but cannot because there are constraints that stop her.

The Job to be Done is the big picture. It encapsulates why customers buy your product(s).

When one innovation wins, another loses. Why?

Because a day has only so many minutes, and a customer can use only one product at a time. For example, every day I used to get an espresso from a coffee shop down the street. Two months ago, I bought a Nespresso machine. Now I make my own espressos. The coffee shop has lost my business.

The theory of Customer Jobs and the idea that customers buy a product to complete a Job to be Done, help us understand all the creative destruction around us.

Once a customer gets a job done, what pushes them to use new products?

When customers make progress (get a job done), new aspirations are often revealed.

The customer's JTBD is part of a system. In Customer Jobs theory, this is called the System of Progress. The system involves the customers, the products, and the innovators.

image

Some examples of how you have new aspirations once you've gotten a job done:

  • You buy your first car and enjoy your newfound independence. But now you want some help planning road trips, choosing car insurance, and finding a mechanic whom you can trust.
  • You buy professional pans and enjoy your increased cooking control. But now you’re curious about new techniques and recipes. You also need to figure out where to store those new pans and how to clean them properly.

My thoughts

This was my first real foray into customer jobs theory (despite it being used at Dropbox). It is really interesting framework to think about product development and your customers. Just having a framework is very helpful relative to trying to figure all this stuff out on your own;